The accidental film school

Ross Gibson and the lost art of the DVD audio commentary 

Featured in

  • Published 20250506
  • ISBN: 978-1-923213-07-4
  • Extent: 196 pp
  • Paperback, ebook, PDF

FOR NIGH ON a decade, there was an email sitting in my inbox that I would intermittently forward to friends who were, like me, planning to travel to Japan. The email – consisting of places to visit, to eat and to rest – had been sent to me by a friend, though I never made the trip (burnout, terminal delays). The list’s author was the polymath Ross Gibson – author, filmmaker, educator – whom I never met in person, despite our timelines having crossed at the University of Technology Sydney, where he was Research Professor of New Media and Digital Culture and I was an unbecoming undergraduate.

As a child, I had spent a year in Niigata, on the west coast of Honshu, attending Yōchien, the Japanese equivalent of kindergarten. I finally made my return trip to Japan in 2023, mounting a pilgrimage to Niigata and following Ross Gibson’s trail through Kyoto, a site he’d visited regularly. This sense of simultaneously communing with both Ross and my childhood in Japan was what subsequently started me collecting a set of DVDs for which Ross had recorded full-length ‘audio commentaries’. On his online CV, Ross itemised these commentaries alongside his many, many books, essays, articles, exhibitions and multimedia works (he was both theorist and practitioner). Yet DVD audio commentaries have long been seen as ancillary material. Quite literally: extras on the menu. Unlike Ross, few would have considered them serious works. Perhaps even less so now. 

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

If you are an educator or student wishing to access content for study purposes please contact us at griffithreview@griffith.edu.au

Share article

About the author

Sam Twyford-Moore

Sam Twyford-Moore is the author of The Rapids: Ways of Looking at Mania (2018) and Cast Mates: Australian Actors in Hollywood and at Home (2023).  His work has...

More from this edition

Nobody panic 

Non-fictionThe desert of the real is now where most teens search for answers to life’s big questions: what is love? Who am I? What is truth? The images of reality we create hold messages about reality. Copies of copies of copies though they may be, they nonetheless have a material effect on our children’s thoughts, behaviours, opinions. Consumerism. Communism. Sexism. Cancelism. Nationalism. Anarchism. Stoicism. Humanism. Ideas about what we should live like, look like and love like, what it means to be a man or a woman, what it means to be an individual or part of a community, are all displayed on a screen in their pockets. The influence is profound, but not necessarily sinister if they are taught to interrogate what they consume.

Trip Advisor review of a protest

Poetry Firstly, what’s with all the footwork? A downward slope would be an attribute. There’s enough gory fundamentalism without toe jam. On that note, can...

A half-century of hatchet jobs

Non-fictionAuthors and publishers worry that bad reviews kill sales. I’ve seen no evidence that this is the case, but plenty that bad reviews distress and demoralise their subjects. Many people who care about literature endow criticism, and especially negative reviews, with magical powers. They hold dear the fantasy that if critics did a better job, if they were braver soldiers, the profound structural problems that bedevil Australian literature – books rushed to press, low pay, policy indifference, plummeting reading rates, crisis in higher education, not to mention the racism and the classism – might somehow disappear. A cracking review ennobles its subject with attention and consideration, but I’ve never seen one earn an author a higher advance on their next book or buy them more time for revision, let alone shift the federal arts budget.

Stay up to date with the latest, news, articles and special offers from Griffith Review.