Material or post-material?

Featured in

  • Published 20090901
  • ISBN: 9781921520761
  • Extent: 264 pp
  • Paperback (234 x 153mm)

THE AMERICAN POLITICAL scientist Ronald Inglehart argues that ‘the basic value priorities of western publics’ shift in affluent times ‘from giving top priority to physical sustenance and safety, toward heavier emphasis on belonging, self-expression and the quality of life’. Inglehart calls this shift in values ‘post-materialism’. It’s an idea that can be traced at least to the mid-1960s, and perhaps even to the pre-Depression ‘flaming youth’ of the 1920s, though it was the late 1960s – the period I call Aquarian liberalism – that saw the most significant shift away from the old politics of base materialism and toward the new progressivism of human rights, environment and community.

Public sentiment about the individual’s relationship with the state has fluctuated like fashions since the nineteenth century. Following the depression of the 1890s, Australians – so often cast as rugged individualists, models of pioneer self-reliance – came to embrace a vigorous union movement, progressive political organisations such as the Protectionists and the Australian Labor Party, and a federalist political structure that would protect them from womb to tomb. Conservative policymakers from Prime Minister Stanley Bruce down later warned against excessive welfare, for fear of transforming Australia into a ‘nation of mendicants’. But the 1950s saw a return to a bi­partisan commitment to what Paul Kelly has labelled the Australian Settlement and, in particular, the welfare state. State paternalism was mandated by both citizen and government.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

If you are an educator or student wishing to access content for study purposes please contact us at

Share article

More from author

Enduring change

EssayPUBLIC INQUIRIES AND their subsequent reports suffer chequered histories in Australia. Some disappear with nary a trace, while others go on to effect real and...

More from this edition

The other side of silence

FictionIT'S TRUE I wanted him dead and would gladly have done it myself. I wonder about the days before fingerprinting, before CCTV, forensic analysis...

The Ministry of Going In

PoetryThis is what happensI go insweep the floorclear the dishesinterview the Secretary of State over a flat whiteand lamingtonand ask about Afghanistan and postmodern...

Stay up to date with the latest, news, articles and special offers from Griffith Review.