Healthcare is other people

Understanding medicine’s specialisation problem 

Featured in

  • Published 20240806
  • ISBN: 978-1-922212-98-6 
  • Extent: 216pp
  • Paperback, ePUB, PDF

IN 1977 A gastroenterologist named Franz Ingelfinger had cancer, a cancer that originated in his gastroenteric tract. He was perhaps the most informed patient imaginable, but that year he presented a lecture at the Harvard Medical School in which he reflected on how difficult it had been to find someone who would take charge of his care when deciding what treatment course to pursue. 

Ingelfinger had already had surgery to remove a tumour but could not reach a decision regarding various possible chemotherapy regimens and the question of whether radiotherapy would be useful in treating potential metastases. As former president of the American Gastroenterological Association and editor of the highly regarded New England Journal of Medicine, he had the finest minds in his profession at his disposal and fielded opinions from many learned colleagues regarding his best course of action. These opinions became so numerous and contradictory that he grew ‘increasingly confused and emotionally distraught’, as he put it. A friend who was also a physician suggested that what Ingelfinger needed was to find a doctor who would ‘in a paternalistic manner assume responsibility for [his] care’. Only when Ingelfinger followed this advice was his distress alleviated.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

If you are an educator or student wishing to access content for study purposes please contact us at griffithreview@griffith.edu.au

Share article

More from author

The geography of respect

Non-fictionStarting in 2019, Parks Victoria closed or restricted access for climbers to much of Gariwerd-Grampians while it assessed cultural heritage and worked with Traditional Owners and conservation experts to develop the Greater Gariwerd Landscape Management Plan (GGLMP). These closures drew strong reactions from many climbers. They saw Parks Victoria’s actions as impinging on their rights, and its apparent focus on climbing as a risk to cultural heritage and environmental integrity as overblown.

More from this edition

The inspirations of radical nostalgia

Non-fictionEnvironmentalism, like history, is a civic discourse that critically engages with change in the world, contemplates the nature of limits and challenges ahistorical self-absorption. Like all good historians, environmentalists create recognition that the structures and conditions of today are not natural, inevitable or preordained but thoroughly contingent. The study of history and ecologically motivated advocacy also both demand reasoned scepticism towards the ideological claims of the powerful.

Put your house in order

In Conversation Poet, performer and musician Pascalle Burton has always been compelled by the visual possibilities of language and the imaginative dynamism of collage. Her multimodal...

Dying of exposure

Non-fictionPublishing is a weird industry, a retail supply service where every day hundreds – thousands – of brand-new, untested products are launched, each one a little bit different to the last. The long-haul career trajectory of most writers is increasingly difficult to maintain with incomes nosediving, as evidenced by multiple surveys. The road is cluttered with novelists brought down by ‘bad track’, their new books rejected because of the poor sales of previous titles. But as readers we still need help to discover good books, to figure out what to read next. As book pages, magazines and newspapers shrink or disappear altogether, it’s no longer clear what impact book reviewers can have on a career. The endorsement of someone whose work – critical or otherwise – you admire remains important to many writers.

Stay up to date with the latest, news, articles and special offers from Griffith Review.