Imperfect bodies of the poor

Featured in

  • Published 20040601
  • ISBN: 9780733314339
  • Extent: 268 pp
  • Paperback (234 x 153mm)

POOR PEOPLE’S BODIES have always told stories about poverty’s origins and remedies. In their own accounts, poor people say their bodies often fail them. But in the stories that are told about them, their bodies more often signal defects of character and effort and even betray them as frauds.

Indeed, the imperfect bodies of the poor are an intriguing barometer for a century’s interpretations of inequality and injustice. In the 1920s and 1930s, Melbourne’s early social workers filled their case notes with tales of evasion and deception. Casting themselves as detectives on the trail of “mendicants”, they helped to cement an understanding of poverty in which “paupers” threatened always to overcome the kindness of their benefactors. In recent years, tales of prematurely dependent, overly fertile, obese or suspiciously frail bodies burdening the taxpayers have played an important role in bolstering the case for early 21st-century welfare reform. In between, the physical sufferings of the poor were taken more as a symbol of a collective failure to protect people against the consequences of illness, infirmity and lack of opportunity.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

If you are an educator or student wishing to access content for study purposes please contact us at

Share article

About the author

Mark Peel

Mark Peel teaches in the school of historical studies at Monash University.He is the author of Good Times, Hard Times: The Past and the Future...

More from this edition

The visibility quest

SatireLAUREN DIAMOND WAS a visibility expert. "Visibility is inversely proportional to size. The eye doesn't register objects, but the space and the movement of...

Journey to the spare world

MemoirI HAVE TO get to Lollipops by 3.30pm and it's not going well. Lollipops is a children's party venue which my support group has...

Our bodies

EssayTHINK OF ABORIGINAL bodies. Think of Cathy Freeman, standing and waiting on the track in Sydney, lean, still, and nothing in her face except...

Stay up to date with the latest, news, articles and special offers from Griffith Review.