Breaking ranks with Empire

Featured in

  • Published 20150414
  • ISBN: 9781922182807
  • Extent: 264 pp
  • Paperback (234 x 153mm), eBook

IN 1920, THE New Zealand official war artist George Edmund Butler presented a painting to the New Zealand Government for the proposed National War Memorial Museum. It is titled Butte de Polygon with the subtitle, Thy Father and I have sought thee sorrowing. Luke II: 48. It depicts an aged couple standing over a soldier’s grave in the wasteland of the Western Front. In the background is the Butte de Polygon at Polygon Wood, to the east of Ypres, in the half circle of hills savagely fought for in the battles of Ypres from 1914 to 1918. This ground was occupied by the New Zealand Division in the winter of 1917–18.

What the picture depicts was the hope of every New Zealand family that had lost a loved one in the First World War. They needed to believe that it was possible to travel across the world and visit a battlefield where their boy had fought and find his grave. The difficulties can be imagined, but Butler understood the powerful emotional impulse of what he portrayed, encapsulated in the words of the subtitle. Most would never be able to attempt such a journey but every family in New Zealand wanted to believe that it was possible and that once there they would find a grave or memorial on the battlefield where he fell.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

If you are an educator or student wishing to access content for study purposes please contact us at

Share article

About the author

Christopher Pugsley

Christopher Pugsley, ONZM, FRHistS, is a former New Zealand army officer, a freelance historian and the author of eighteen books. His book Gallipoli: The...

More from this edition

The uses and abuses of humiliation

MemoirOne year I said I didn’t Want to be arrested. Back too frail to be man-handled. I settled for the dawn peace-vigil: Candles flickering in the police horse’s...

Continuing fallout

EssayTHE STORY OF Japan’s marriage to nuclear energy is so fraught with suffering, you have to wonder why they ever got together.Just what are...


GR Online All images © Nadia Wheatley   I VIVIDLY REMEMBER my reaction when I discovered that my father had worked at Belsen. This revelation came in 1983, a...

Stay up to date with the latest, news, articles and special offers from Griffith Review.