The rhetoric of reaction

Featured in

  • Published 20050607
  • ISBN: 9780733316081
  • Extent: 264 pp
  • Paperback (234 x 153mm)

RHETORIC WAS UNDERSTOOD by Aristotle to include those many, often refined, techniques of argumentation unavoidable in domains of life, such as politics and law, where persuasion is necessary but conclusive demonstration is unavailable. It is unavoidable, significant and there are good and bad forms of it. As Samuel Goldwyn might observe, however, we’ve passed a lot of water since then. Today, “rhetoric” is almost always spoken of pejoratively, and more often than not, dismissively: words without weight (“empty rhetoric”), which add nothing but adornment (“mere rhetoric”). If, in Australia, it is already suspicious to be eloquent, it is unpardonable to be rhetorical.

What I have in mind is somewhere between the refined and the corrupt. The sorts of rhetoric I discuss here are significant, but none of them is to be recommended. Certainly, they are all about persuasion. I’m not a fan of them, but they’re not “mere” hot air, or sweet words, or just style as opposed to substance. Indeed, they’re not mere anything and they are far from empty. They have their role and significance in public debate.

Already a subscriber? Sign in here

If you are an educator or student wishing to access content for study purposes please contact us at

Share article

About the author

Martin Krygier

Martin Krygier is Professor of Law at the University of New South Wales, and co-director of its European Law Centre. In 1997, he delivered...

More from this edition

Imagination the everyday art

EssayA WRITER, AN actor. A mother, a daughter. The mother captured and lingered in the public memory when she chained herself to a bar...

The trouble with empathy

EssayNo doubt the finite and meagre nature of our feelings does prevent us from extending our sympathies to those whom we have not seen...

Habits of inclusion

GR OnlineAUSTRALIA'S UNLIKELIEST TELEVISION presenter, Peter Cundall, recently conducted viewers of the ABC TV's Gardening Australia on a tour of his garden in the Tamar Valley, Tasmania....

Stay up to date with the latest, news, articles and special offers from Griffith Review.